http://salaamsblog.wordpress.com/2008/04/24/ahmadiyya-muslims-what-next/ Justice, Equality, and Freedom: An American Muslim's thoughts and perspectives about the Muslim American experience, Politics, Religion, Spirituality, and Life through Islam. Fri, 04 Jul 2008 07:29:41 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=MU http://salaamsblog.wordpress.com/2008/04/24/ahmadiyya-muslims-what-next/#comment-12007 Arif Ahmed Sun, 04 May 2008 23:35:57 +0000 http://salaamsblog.wordpress.com/?p=388#comment-12007 Hello Yusuf smith, I read your comments about Ahmadiyya. Looks like you are not familar with Ahmadiyya beliefs and practice. They do believe in finality of prophethood of Muhmmad (SAW). It is just a matter of interpretation of word 'Prophet'. If Ahmaides are Kafir because of this than yor will call all those Isalmic scholars 'Kafir' who actually did the same expalination of Umati Naabi as Mirza Sahib did and calimed. This is not a prophethood against Islam. And you believe in Jesus Christ coming back. Aren't you? than what will happen to the finality of prophethood. How your Imam ul Mahdi know that he is Imam appointed by Allah, if there is no Nubwah and no Wahi? Last thing, i think you have every right to believe that Ahmadies are Kafir and i respect that but you do not have any right to not allow them call themselves as Muslims. Who gave you this right? Hello Yusuf smith, I read your comments about Ahmadiyya. Looks like you are not familar with Ahmadiyya beliefs and practice. They do believe in finality of prophethood of Muhmmad (SAW). It is just a matter of interpretation of word ‘Prophet’. If Ahmaides are Kafir because of this than yor will call all those Isalmic scholars ‘Kafir’ who actually did the same expalination of Umati Naabi as Mirza Sahib did and calimed. This is not a prophethood against Islam. And you believe in Jesus Christ coming back. Aren’t you? than what will happen to the finality of prophethood. How your Imam ul Mahdi know that he is Imam appointed by Allah, if there is no Nubwah and no Wahi?
Last thing, i think you have every right to believe that Ahmadies are Kafir and i respect that but you do not have any right to not allow them call themselves as Muslims. Who gave you this right?

]]> http://salaamsblog.wordpress.com/2008/04/24/ahmadiyya-muslims-what-next/#comment-11941 Hazeem Mon, 28 Apr 2008 18:20:19 +0000 http://salaamsblog.wordpress.com/?p=388#comment-11941 God Bless You for being righteous. God Bless You for being righteous.

]]> http://salaamsblog.wordpress.com/2008/04/24/ahmadiyya-muslims-what-next/#comment-11912 Yusuf Smith Sat, 26 Apr 2008 10:44:15 +0000 http://salaamsblog.wordpress.com/?p=388#comment-11912 It is not Muslims who declare Qadianis to be non-Muslims; they are non-Muslims by fact of what they believe, which is that there was a prophet after Muhammad (sall' Allahu 'alaihi wa sallam). This is kufr, pure and simple, before we even entertain the bizarre ideas their so-called prophet came out with. We know how the salaf dealt with false prophets and their followers such as Musaylima; if they had not had the protection of the British empire in India, they would have got the same treatment. Finality of Prophethood is a basic tenet of Islam; any minimally educated Muslim knows that there are no more prophets in Arabia, India or anywhere else. We should not sanction mob violence or any other injustice towards them, but we certainly should not allow them to call themselves Muslims and deceive people (as they are apt to do, as I have personally witnessed in south London where they have a substantial presence) when they are plainly not. It is not Muslims who declare Qadianis to be non-Muslims; they are non-Muslims by fact of what they believe, which is that there was a prophet after Muhammad (sall’ Allahu ‘alaihi wa sallam). This is kufr, pure and simple, before we even entertain the bizarre ideas their so-called prophet came out with. We know how the salaf dealt with false prophets and their followers such as Musaylima; if they had not had the protection of the British empire in India, they would have got the same treatment. Finality of Prophethood is a basic tenet of Islam; any minimally educated Muslim knows that there are no more prophets in Arabia, India or anywhere else. We should not sanction mob violence or any other injustice towards them, but we certainly should not allow them to call themselves Muslims and deceive people (as they are apt to do, as I have personally witnessed in south London where they have a substantial presence) when they are plainly not.

]]>